5

I think my question is pretty clear

I would like to Merge customer_id from table user to table cust where customers_firstname AND customers_name match

And I attached two images
In fact it was answered immediately
it was upvoted

someone edited my question as code

I would like to Merge customer_id from table user to table cust where customers_firstname AND customers_name match

And my question was closed as

closed as unclear what you're asking

once it was incorrectly edited as code it was unclear, all you saw was 2 images and a line of code.

  • 3
    well if it wasnt closed as "unclear" then it's certainly a dupe. – swasheck Jun 16 '15 at 16:48
9

The displayed close reason reflects a simple majority of the five community close votes cast.

The question isn't at all unclear to me, so that is not the reason I chose personally when voting. As I recall, I voted to migrate it to Stack Overflow, which is often a better fit for more basic questions.

Looking at the question history, I cannot immediately see why anyone would vote to close it as "unclear what you're asking" at any stage, but it could be closed for other reasons: as a duplicate, too localized, or for migration to SO.

The individual vote reasons are not visible to me, and perhaps not even to moderators, I'm not too sure about that. Perhaps there were two votes to close as unclear, and the other three votes were split over three different reasons.

So, it seems to me the question is closed (to new answers) correctly, just for the 'wrong' (or at least, 'unhelpful') displayed reason. Sorry about that.

  • 1
    don't you think it's irrelevant?, 3 users agree it should be closed for different reasons all 3 agree that it's clear, 2 users agree it should be closed since it's unclear, you have 3 against two = clear, 5 agree it should be moved or closed, not clear wins – yesitsme Jun 18 '15 at 23:06
  • 2
    @yesitsme your comment is unclear to me. I'm voting to close it. – Max Vernon Jun 19 '15 at 19:46
  • 4
    @yesitsme If I vote to close a question as e.g. too broad, it doesn't necessarily mean I don't also consider it unclear. (Actually, sometimes it is really hard to choose between these two particular reasons.) But regardless of that, which reason do you propose to show in the discussed scenario? None of the reasons has the majority of votes – therefore, a different rule should be used. Choosing the reason that's got more votes than any other one is a perfectly sensible rule. Anyway, maybe the real issue in this situation is that only one reason gets chosen for display. – Andriy M Jun 19 '15 at 20:04

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .