3

This post reappeared on dba.stackexchange a few minutes ago (01:20 UTC), but the person who asked the original question hasn't visited the site for almost 9 months.

Why should questions by people who don't bother to visit regularly be recycled? I actually like the idea of recycling - it gives posters whose posts have fallen off the radar a second crack of the whip. However, this "bonus" should, I feel, only be given to those who make the effort to drop in from time to time. Any thoughts?

7

The reason it was bumped is that it was modified by the community user:

enter image description here

You are right that it was to get attention for an unanswered post. The algorithm is different per site, but it doesn't take the user's presence into account - likely for reasons already discussed: why does it matter if that user didn't stick around? If it was a good question, or at least not a bad question (as shown by the non-negative score), doesn't it still deserve an answer, for the benefit of the site and the community, if not for the original user? Also, remember that the asker may not seem to still be around, but he/she actually could be - they could be lurking, or using a different account (this is certainly common when someone has had a question migrated here).

I don't think we really have any control over this on our site, and you'd have to make a pretty compelling argument that bumping this post was somehow bad in order to make any changes that would make us special:

The Community user will bump non-negatively scored questions that have at least one answer scoring 0 and none scoring more than that. The number of unanswered questions bumped per hour depends on the site: 4 per hour on Stack Overflow, 1 per hour on Meta, and 2 per hour on Super User and Server Fault. The default for a new site is 1 per hour.

You can get more background here and here.

  • Thanks for the clarification. – Vérace Aug 24 '14 at 2:53
5

Maybe as a variation, your question needs to be upvoted (to ensure it's a worthwhile question)? Or combine the two - in order for a community bump, the question needs to be upvoted and you have to have been active within the past month?

  • Good point - some questions are of interest no matter who asks them. I'll give a +1 to a combination of either user activity and/or upvotes (maybe 2?). – Vérace Aug 24 '14 at 1:40
  • bear in mind it's the answers that need upvotes to not get re-bumped – jcolebrand Aug 26 '14 at 13:33

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .